[molpro-user] Size consistency issue

Lorenzo Lodi l.lodi at ucl.ac.uk
Fri Feb 12 17:49:37 CET 2016


Hello George,
I had a look at this using small basis sets and I found results similar
to yours, ie the CASSCF energies are not size-consistent in this case.
So `trivial' errors such as incorrect convergence or getting the wrong
electronic states should be excluded.
Specifically:

1) Using the small STO-3G basis set CASSCF is FCI in the valence space,
and in this case the energies *are* size consistent. I get using MCSCF
E1=-73.804150 for O, E2=-73.443584 for O+, E1+E2=-147.247734 which is
also the value I get for O2+ at r=100 a0.

2) Using 6-31G or cc-pVDZ the sum of the atomic energies is lower than
the energy of stretched O2+ by about 0.0047 Eh, as you reported in the
aug-cc-pV5Z basis set.
On the other hand if we do FCI using the MCSCF orbitals we get
size-consistent energies (attached outputs).
As suggested by Kirk, perhaps different virtual orbitals enter into the
active space (AS) in the molecular and atomic cases. If you want to
investigate this further I'd have a look at the orbital expansion
coefficients (use ORBPRINT) in the atomic and molecular cases (using the
smallest basis set which reproduces the problem, eg 6-31G or even
smaller) and see if you can understand what is going into the AS.

I also point out that in this sistem there are lots of degeneracies. In
the atomic calculation (attached) I average over the spacial components
(3 components for oxygen 3P and 1 component for oxygen+ 4S^o), while for
the molecule I average over the two degenerate components of the 2Pi_g
term. At r=infty a part from 2Pi_g there is also a 2Pi_u and two
2Sigma_g^+ terms, as well as {2Pi_g, 2Pi_u, 2x2Sigma_g^+} quadruplets
and sextets, I wonder if the size-consistency violation you observed is
related to which states are included and averaged over.

Lorenzo

On 10/02/16 18:36, george wrote:
> Dear molpro users
>
>
>        I am computing potential energy curve for ground state O2+ at
> multi level using av5z basis set. This dissociates to O(3P)+O+(4S)
> fragments. Now I add the energies of these two fragments and get
> -149.18369960 hartrees at the same level. When I look at the energies
> of curve at 100 angstrom, the multi value at this long distance is 
> -149.13557933 hartrees. I wonder why and how this numerical
> discrepancies arise? My input file is very simple without any
> complicated keyworkds. Am I missing something relevent to this type of
> problem? Any suggestion please.
>
>
> My input
>
>  ***,o2+
>  memory,125,m
>  print,orbitals,civector
>                                                                                 
> !file,1,o2+_ci_d2h_6_1_mar5.int <http://ci_d2h_6_1_mar5.int>
>                                                                                 
> !file,2,o2+_ci_d2h_6_1_mar5.wfu
>                        
> !symmetry,nosym                                                                                
> !symmetry,x
>                                                         
> !rcm=[1.11780256,0.7,0.75,0.8,0.85,0.9,0.95,1,1.025,1.05,1.075,1.1,1.110,\
>                                                                            
> !      1.125,1.15,1.175,1.2,1.25,1.3,1.35,1.4,1.5,1.6,\
>  !     
> 1.7,1.8,1.9,2,2.125,2.25,2.5,2.75,3,3.25,3.375,3.5,3.625,3.75,4,4.25,4.5,4.75,5,5.25,5.5,5.75,6,6.5,7,7.5,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,18,20,21,22,23,24,25]
> ANG
>  rcm=[100] ANG
>
>  geometry                                                                       
> !geometry specification, using z-matrix
>  o1
>  o2,o1,r
>  end
>
>  basis=aug-cc-pV5Z
>
>  do i=1,#rcm
>
>  r=rcm(i)
>
>  {multi;maxiter,40;config;pspace,0.1;wf,15,7,1;dm}
>  emulti_gs(i)=energy(1)
>                                                                                 
> !{ci;option,maxiti=10000;wf,15,6,1}
>                                                                                 
> !eci_gs(i)=energy(1)
>                                                                                 
> !eci_david(i)=energd(1)
>
>  {table,rcm,emulti_gs
>  Title,Results for O2+ dissociation 2Pi_g state
>  format,'(f15.8,f30.15)'}
>
>                                                                                 
> !{table,rcm,eci_gs
>                                                                                 
> !format,'(f15.8,f30.15)'}
>
>                                                                                 
> !{table,rcm,eci_david
>                                                                                 
> !format,'(f15.8,f30.15)'}
>
>  end do
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Molpro-user mailing list
> Molpro-user at molpro.net
> http://www.molpro.net/mailman/listinfo/molpro-user

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.molpro.net/pipermail/molpro-user/attachments/20160212/866f0470/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------

 Primary working directories    : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Secondary working directories  : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Wavefunction directory         : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Main file repository           : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/

 SHA1      : 2c68d29c09da70e1723824271fadde4bcd5f07a0
 ARCHNAME  : Linux/x86_64
 FC        : /usr/bin/gfortran
 FCVERSION : 4.4.6
 BLASLIB   : -L/usr/lib64/atlas -lf77blas -lcblas -latlas
 id        : uclcc

 Nodes                            nprocs
 secondprize.theory.phys.ucl.ac.uk    1

 Using customized tuning parameters: mindgm=1; mindgv=20; mindgc=4; mindgr=1; noblas=0; minvec=7
 default implementation of scratch files=df  

 ***,Calculation for SH === Input for MOLPRO 2010
 MEMORY,     500.00, M
 GEXPEC, DM, REL, DARW, MASSV
 GTHRESH, ZERO=5.e-13, TWOINT=5.e-13, ENERGY=2.e-9, GRADIENT=1.e-3, ORBITAL=2.e-6, CIVEC=1.e-5, COEFF=1.e-5, PRINTCI=0.01
 GPRINT, DISTANCE, ANGLES, VARIABLE
 
 basis={default, STO-3G}
 
 geometry = {O1; O2, O1, r}
 
 r=  100.00000000
 {MCSCF
  ACCURACY, ENERGY=5.e-10;
  OCC, 3,1,1,0,3,1,1,0; CLOSED,1,0,0,0,1,0,0,0; FROZEN,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0;
  PSPACE,0.1
  WF, ELEC=15, SYM=2, SPIN=1; LQUANT,1;
  WF, ELEC=15, SYM=3, SPIN=1; LQUANT,1;
  }
 
 
 basis={default, 6-31G}
 {MCSCF;ORBPRINT,10
  ACCURACY, ENERGY=5.e-10;
  OCC, 3,1,1,0,3,1,1,0; CLOSED,1,0,0,0,1,0,0,0; FROZEN,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0;
  PSPACE,0.1
  WF, ELEC=15, SYM=2, SPIN=1; LQUANT,1;
  WF, ELEC=15, SYM=3, SPIN=1; LQUANT,1;
 }
 
 {FCI; CORE,1,0,0,0,1,0,0,0}
 
                                                                                !SHOW[f30.8] energy+74.786188040053+74.348254981015
 
 

 Variables initialized (766), CPU time= 0.01 sec
 Commands  initialized (545), CPU time= 0.02 sec, 513 directives.
 Default parameters read. Elapsed time= 0.06 sec

 Checking input...
 Passed
1


                                         ***  PROGRAM SYSTEM MOLPRO  ***
                         Copyright, University College Cardiff Consultants Limited, 2008

                                    Version 2012.1 linked 26 Apr 2013 18:03:55


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 LABEL *   Calculation for SH ==- Input for MOLPRO 2010                                  
 Linux-2.6.32-573.12.1.el6.x86_64/secondprize.theory.phys.ucl.ac.uk(x86_64) 64 bit serialDATE: 12-Feb-16          TIME: 16:12:49  
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

 SHA1:             2c68d29c09da70e1723824271fadde4bcd5f07a0
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

 THRESHOLDS:

 ZERO    =  5.00D-13  ONEINT  =  1.00D-12  TWOINT  =  5.00D-13  PREFAC  =  1.00D-14  LOCALI  =  1.00D-09  EORDER  =  1.00D-04
 ENERGY  =  2.00D-09  ETEST   =  0.00D+00  EDENS   =  0.00D+00  THRDEDEF=  1.00D-06  GRADIENT=  1.00D-03  STEP    =  1.00D-03
 ORBITAL =  2.00D-06  CIVEC   =  1.00D-05  COEFF   =  1.00D-05  PRINTCI =  1.00D-02  PUNCHCI =  9.90D+01  OPTGRAD =  3.00D-04
 OPTENERG=  1.00D-06  OPTSTEP =  3.00D-04  THRGRAD =  1.00D-10  COMPRESS=  1.00D-11  VARMIN  =  1.00D-07  VARMAX  =  1.00D-03
 THRDOUB =  0.00D+00  THRDIV  =  1.00D-05  THRRED  =  1.00D-07  THRPSP  =  1.00D+00  THRDC   =  1.00D-10  THRCS   =  1.00D-10
 THRNRM  =  1.00D-08  THREQ   =  0.00D+00  THRDE   =  1.00D+00  THRREF  =  1.00D-05  SPARFAC =  1.00D+00  THRDLP  =  1.00D-07
 THRDIA  =  1.00D-10  THRDLS  =  1.00D-07  THRGPS  =  0.00D+00  THRKEX  =  0.00D+00  THRDIS  =  2.00D-01  THRVAR  =  1.00D-10
 THRLOC  =  1.00D-06  THRGAP  =  1.00D-06  THRLOCT = -1.00D+00  THRGAPT = -1.00D+00  THRORB  =  1.00D-06  THRMLTP =  0.00D+00
 THRCPQCI=  1.00D-10  KEXTA   =  0.00D+00  THRCOARS=  0.00D+00  SYMTOL  =  1.00D-06  GRADTOL =  1.00D-06  THROVL  =  1.00D-08
 THRORTH =  1.00D-08  GRID    =  1.00D-06  GRIDMAX =  1.00D-03  DTMAX   =  0.00D+00  THROCCDE=  1.00D-01  THROCCDE=  1.00D-01




 Variable memory set to  500000000 words,  buffer space   230000 words

 SETTING BASIS          =    STO-3G
 SETTING R              =       100.00000000                                  


 Recomputing integrals since basis changed


 Using spherical harmonics

 Library entry O      S STO-3G               selected for orbital group  1
 Library entry O      P STO-3G               selected for orbital group  1

1PROGRAM * SEWARD (Integral evaluation for generally contracted gaussian basis sets)     Author: Roland Lindh, 1990

 Geometry written to block  1 of record 700

 Orientation using atomic masses  
 Molecule type: Linear
 Symmetry elements: X,Y,Z
 Rotational constants:       0.0225601      0.0225601      0.0000000 GHz  (calculated with average atomic masses)

 Point group  D2h 



 ATOMIC COORDINATES

 NR  ATOM    CHARGE       X              Y              Z

   1  O1      8.00    0.000000000    0.000000000  -50.000000000
   2  O2      8.00    0.000000000    0.000000000   50.000000000

 NUCLEAR CHARGE:                   16
 NUMBER OF PRIMITIVE AOS:          30
 NUMBER OF SYMMETRY AOS:           30
 NUMBER OF CONTRACTIONS:           10   (   3Ag  +   1B3u +   1B2u +   0B1g +   3B1u +   1B2g +   1B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF CORE ORBITALS:           2   (   1Ag  +   0B3u +   0B2u +   0B1g +   1B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF VALENCE ORBITALS:        8   (   2Ag  +   1B3u +   1B2u +   0B1g +   2B1u +   1B2g +   1B3g +   0Au  )


 NUCLEAR REPULSION ENERGY    0.64000000


 Eigenvalues of metric

         1 0.763E+00 0.100E+01 0.124E+01
         2 0.100E+01
         3 0.100E+01
         5 0.763E+00 0.100E+01 0.124E+01
         6 0.100E+01
         7 0.100E+01


 Contracted 2-electron integrals neglected if value below      1.0D-14
 AO integral compression algorithm  1   Integral accuracy      1.0D-14

     0.262 MB (compressed) written to integral file (100.0%)


 NUMBER OF SORTED TWO-ELECTRON INTEGRALS:        373.     BUFFER LENGTH:  32768
 NUMBER OF SEGMENTS:   1  SEGMENT LENGTH:        373      RECORD LENGTH: 524288

 Memory used in sort:       0.56 MW

 SORT1 READ         776. AND WROTE         373. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.00 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.00 SEC
 SORT2 READ         373. AND WROTE         373. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.00 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.01 SEC

 FILE SIZES:   FILE 1:     7.8 MBYTE,  FILE 4:     4.2 MBYTE,   TOTAL:     12.0 MBYTE

 OPERATOR DM      FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR REL     FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR DARW    FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR MASSV   FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      19        7.51       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.41      0.03
 REAL TIME  *         0.44 SEC
 DISK USED  *        12.26 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

1PROGRAM * MULTI (Direct Multiconfiguration SCF)       Authors: P.J. Knowles, H.-J. Werner (1984)     S.T. Elbert (1988)


 Number of closed-shell orbitals:   2 (   1   0   0   0   1   0   0   0 )
 Number of active  orbitals:        8 (   2   1   1   0   2   1   1   0 )
 Number of external orbitals:       0 (   0   0   0   0   0   0   0   0 )

 State symmetry 1

  State symmetry 1:     Projection for operator LZ       squared   value = 1

 Number of electrons:    11    Spin symmetry=Doublet   Space symmetry=2
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:        126   (196 determinants, 1568 intermediate states)

 State symmetry 2

  State symmetry 2:     Projection for operator LZ       squared   value = 1

 Number of electrons:    11    Spin symmetry=Doublet   Space symmetry=3
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:        126   (196 determinants, 1568 intermediate states)

 Orbital guess generated from atomic densities. Full valence occupancy:    3   1   1   0   3   1   1   0


 Wavefunction dump at record             2140.2

 Convergence thresholds  0.10E-02 (gradient)  0.50E-09 (energy)  0.10E-02 (step length)

 Weight factors for state symmetry  1:    0.50000
 Weight factors for state symmetry  2:    0.50000

 Number of orbital rotations:        4   (     4 Core/Active      0 Core/Virtual   0 Active/Active      0 Active/Virtual)
 Total number of variables:        396


 ITER. MIC  NCI  NEG     ENERGY(VAR)     ENERGY(PROJ)   ENERGY CHANGE     GRAD(0)  GRAD(ORB)   GRAD(CI)     STEP       TIME

 *** WARNING *** <S**2> =  0.750000002
 ANNIHILATE S =  1.5 COMPONENT
 *** WARNING *** <S**2> =  0.750000006
 ANNIHILATE S =  2.5 COMPONENT
 FINAL VALUES OF <S**2>    0.750000000
   1   15  108    0    -147.24773391    -147.24773391   -0.00000000    0.00000242 0.00000000 0.00000031  0.12D-06      0.10

 ** WVFN ****  CONVERGENCE REACHED, FINAL GRADIENT:  0.17D-09



 Results for state 1.2
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.2 Energy             -147.247733912416
 Nuclear energy                         0.64000000
 Kinetic energy                       144.36118654
 One electron energy                 -200.50798498
 Two electron energy                   52.62025107
 Virial ratio                           2.01999531

 !MCSCF STATE 1.2 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000



 Results for state 1.3
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.3 Energy             -147.247733912416
 Nuclear energy                         0.64000000
 Kinetic energy                       144.36118654
 One electron energy                 -200.50798498
 Two electron energy                   52.62025107
 Virial ratio                           2.01999531

 !MCSCF STATE 1.3 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000

 State-averaged charge density matrix saved on record  2140.2 (density set 1)

 !MCSCF expec        <1.2|EREL|1.2>    -0.075308837925
 !MCSCF expec        <1.3|EREL|1.3>    -0.075308837925

 !MCSCF expec      <1.2|DARWIN|1.2>     0.259948622117
 !MCSCF expec      <1.3|DARWIN|1.3>     0.259948622117

 !MCSCF expec       <1.2|MASSV|1.2>    -0.335257460042
 !MCSCF expec       <1.3|MASSV|1.3>    -0.335257460042


 Natural orbital dump (state averaged) at molpro section  2140.2    (Orbital set 2)



 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      21        7.52       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700     1380   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER     JKOP   
                                         1700(1)
                                         OPER   

              2       4        0.29       700     1000      520     2140   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.53      0.12      0.03
 REAL TIME  *         0.59 SEC
 DISK USED  *        13.74 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 SETTING BASIS          =    6-31G


 Recomputing integrals since basis changed


 Using spherical harmonics

 Library entry O      S 6-31G                selected for orbital group  1
 Library entry O      P 6-31G                selected for orbital group  1

1PROGRAM * SEWARD (Integral evaluation for generally contracted gaussian basis sets)     Author: Roland Lindh, 1990

 Geometry written to block  1 of record 700

 Orientation using atomic masses  
 Molecule type: Linear
 Symmetry elements: X,Y,Z
 Rotational constants:       0.0225601      0.0225601      0.0000000 GHz  (calculated with average atomic masses)

 Point group  D2h 



 ATOMIC COORDINATES

 NR  ATOM    CHARGE       X              Y              Z

   1  O1      8.00    0.000000000    0.000000000  -50.000000000
   2  O2      8.00    0.000000000    0.000000000   50.000000000

 NUCLEAR CHARGE:                   16
 NUMBER OF PRIMITIVE AOS:          44
 NUMBER OF SYMMETRY AOS:           44
 NUMBER OF CONTRACTIONS:           18   (   5Ag  +   2B3u +   2B2u +   0B1g +   5B1u +   2B2g +   2B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF CORE ORBITALS:           2   (   1Ag  +   0B3u +   0B2u +   0B1g +   1B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF VALENCE ORBITALS:        8   (   2Ag  +   1B3u +   1B2u +   0B1g +   2B1u +   1B2g +   1B3g +   0Au  )


 NUCLEAR REPULSION ENERGY    0.64000000


 Eigenvalues of metric

         1 0.233E+00 0.498E+00 0.909E+00 0.150E+01 0.186E+01
         2 0.498E+00 0.150E+01
         3 0.498E+00 0.150E+01
         5 0.233E+00 0.498E+00 0.909E+00 0.150E+01 0.186E+01
         6 0.498E+00 0.150E+01
         7 0.498E+00 0.150E+01


 Contracted 2-electron integrals neglected if value below      1.0D-14
 AO integral compression algorithm  1   Integral accuracy      1.0D-14

     0.262 MB (compressed) written to integral file (100.0%)


 NUMBER OF SORTED TWO-ELECTRON INTEGRALS:       2829.     BUFFER LENGTH:  32768
 NUMBER OF SEGMENTS:   1  SEGMENT LENGTH:       2829      RECORD LENGTH: 524288

 Memory used in sort:       0.56 MW

 SORT1 READ        8184. AND WROTE        2829. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.00 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.01 SEC
 SORT2 READ        2829. AND WROTE        2829. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.01 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.01 SEC

 FILE SIZES:   FILE 1:     7.8 MBYTE,  FILE 4:     4.2 MBYTE,   TOTAL:     12.0 MBYTE

 OPERATOR DM      FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR REL     FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR DARW    FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR MASSV   FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      19        7.54       500      610      700      900      950      970     1001      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER   

              2       5        0.31       700     1000      520     2140     1001   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF    BASIS   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL       INT     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.62      0.02      0.12      0.03
 REAL TIME  *         0.71 SEC
 DISK USED  *        13.74 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

1PROGRAM * MULTI (Direct Multiconfiguration SCF)       Authors: P.J. Knowles, H.-J. Werner (1984)     S.T. Elbert (1988)


 Number of closed-shell orbitals:   2 (   1   0   0   0   1   0   0   0 )
 Number of active  orbitals:        8 (   2   1   1   0   2   1   1   0 )
 Number of external orbitals:       8 (   2   1   1   0   2   1   1   0 )

 State symmetry 1

  State symmetry 1:     Projection for operator LZ       squared   value = 1

 Number of electrons:    11    Spin symmetry=Doublet   Space symmetry=2
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:        126   (196 determinants, 1568 intermediate states)

 State symmetry 2

  State symmetry 2:     Projection for operator LZ       squared   value = 1

 Number of electrons:    11    Spin symmetry=Doublet   Space symmetry=3
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:        126   (196 determinants, 1568 intermediate states)

 Molecular orbitals read from record     2140.2  Type=MCSCF/NATURAL  

 Present basis size:       5   2   2   0   5   2   2
 Previous basis size:      3   1   1   0   3   1   1
 Previous occupation:      3   1   1   0   3   1   1
 Previous closed-shells:   1   0   0   0   1   0   0
 Present occupation:       3   1   1   0   3   1   1
 Present closed-shells:    1   0   0   0   1   0   0
 Wavefunction symmetry:    2   Doublet 

 Orbital overlap <old|new>:  < 1.1| 1.1> = 0.999844   < 1.5| 1.5> = 0.999844   < 2.1| 2.1> = 0.998325   < 3.1| 3.1> = 0.994535
                             < 1.2| 1.2> = 0.994535   < 1.3| 1.3> = 0.994535   < 2.5| 2.5> = 0.998325   < 3.5| 3.5> = 0.994535
                             < 1.6| 1.6> = 0.994535   < 1.7| 1.7> = 0.994535

 Wavefunction dump at record             2141.2

 Convergence thresholds  0.10E-02 (gradient)  0.50E-09 (energy)  0.10E-02 (step length)

 Weight factors for state symmetry  1:    0.50000
 Weight factors for state symmetry  2:    0.50000

 Number of orbital rotations:       20   (     4 Core/Active      4 Core/Virtual   0 Active/Active     12 Active/Virtual)
 Total number of variables:        412


 ITER. MIC  NCI  NEG     ENERGY(VAR)     ENERGY(PROJ)   ENERGY CHANGE     GRAD(0)  GRAD(ORB)   GRAD(CI)     STEP       TIME

 *** WARNING *** <S**2> =  0.750000002
 ANNIHILATE S =  1.5 COMPONENT
 *** WARNING *** <S**2> =  0.750000005
 ANNIHILATE S =  2.5 COMPONENT
 FINAL VALUES OF <S**2>    0.750000000
 *** WARNING *** <S**2> =  0.750000024
 ANNIHILATE S =  1.5 COMPONENT
 *** WARNING *** <S**2> =  0.750000065
 ANNIHILATE S =  2.5 COMPONENT
 FINAL VALUES OF <S**2>    0.750000000
   1   24  124    0    -149.00676906    -149.06509542   -0.05832636    0.71271557 0.00121539 0.00095931  0.15D+00      0.12
   2   47   50    0    -149.06603224    -149.06607771   -0.00004548    0.01031616 0.00000386 0.00011568  0.46D-02      0.16
   3   33   34    0    -149.06607774    -149.06607774   -0.00000000    0.00001243 0.00000001 0.00000239  0.73D-04      0.21

 ** WVFN ****  CONVERGENCE REACHED, FINAL GRADIENT:  0.14D-06



 Results for state 1.2
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.2 Energy             -149.066077739076
 Nuclear energy                         0.64000000
 Kinetic energy                       148.80789431
 One electron energy                 -202.76972672
 Two electron energy                   53.06364898
 Virial ratio                           2.00173501

 !MCSCF STATE 1.2 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000



 Results for state 1.3
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.3 Energy             -149.066077739076
 Nuclear energy                         0.64000000
 Kinetic energy                       148.80789431
 One electron energy                 -202.76972672
 Two electron energy                   53.06364898
 Virial ratio                           2.00173501

 !MCSCF STATE 1.3 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000

 State-averaged charge density matrix saved on record  2141.2 (density set 1)

 !MCSCF expec        <1.2|EREL|1.2>    -0.103309035223
 !MCSCF expec        <1.3|EREL|1.3>    -0.103309035224

 !MCSCF expec      <1.2|DARWIN|1.2>     0.391868067484
 !MCSCF expec      <1.3|DARWIN|1.3>     0.391868067484

 !MCSCF expec       <1.2|MASSV|1.2>    -0.495177102707
 !MCSCF expec       <1.3|MASSV|1.3>    -0.495177102708


 NATURAL ORBITALS (state averaged)
 =================================

   Orb     Occ        Energy       Coefficients

                                   1 1s      1 1s      1 1s      1 2pz     1 2pz  

   1.1  2.00000   -21.016506     1.001478  0.005285 -0.016727 -0.000001 -0.000001

   2.1  2.00000    -1.538587    -0.211101  0.589647  0.500527  0.000033  0.000034

   3.1  1.00000    -0.548073     0.000015 -0.000065  0.000003  0.756123  0.377147

   4.1 -0.00000     0.861202     0.000049 -0.000664  0.000656 -0.874256  1.092614

   5.1 -0.00000     0.947748     0.102858 -1.455874  1.465906  0.000379 -0.000502

                                   1 2px     1 2px  

   1.2  1.15931    -0.627406     0.732597  0.406082

   2.2 -0.00000     0.867176    -0.894062  1.082194

                                   1 2py     1 2py  

   1.3  1.15931    -0.627406     0.732597  0.406082

   2.3 -0.00000     0.867176    -0.894062  1.082194

                                   1 1s      1 1s      1 1s      1 2pz     1 2pz  

   1.5  2.00000   -21.016500     1.001479  0.005281 -0.016730 -0.000001 -0.000001

   2.5  2.00000    -1.538594    -0.211094  0.589647  0.500527  0.000033  0.000034

   3.5  1.00000    -0.548073     0.000015 -0.000065  0.000003  0.756123  0.377147

   4.5 -0.00000     0.861202     0.000049 -0.000664  0.000656 -0.874256  1.092614

   5.5 -0.00000     0.947748     0.102858 -1.455874  1.465906  0.000379 -0.000502

                                   1 2px     1 2px  

   1.6  1.34070    -0.629579     0.724055  0.416362

   2.6 -0.00000     0.868443    -0.900994  1.078280

                                   1 2py     1 2py  

   1.7  1.34070    -0.629579     0.724055  0.416362

   2.7 -0.00000     0.868443    -0.900994  1.078280

 Total charge:   1.000000000000


 Natural orbital dump (state averaged) at molpro section  2141.2    (Orbital set 2)



 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      21        7.58       500      610      700      900      950      970     1001      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700     1380   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER     JKOP   
                                         1700(1)
                                         OPER   

              2       6        0.34       700     1000      520     2140     1001     2141   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF    BASIS    MCSCF   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL     MCSCF       INT     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.85      0.23      0.02      0.12      0.03
 REAL TIME  *         1.02 SEC
 DISK USED  *        13.87 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

1PROGRAM * FCI (Full CI)     Author: P.J. Knowles, 1984

 ***  Initialisation ***

 Molecular orbitals read from record     2141.2  Type=MCSCF/NATURAL  

 Frozen orbitals:              2 (  1  0  0  0  1  0  0  0)
 Active orbitals:             16 (  4  2  2  0  4  2  2  0)
 Active electrons:            11
 Spin quantum number:          0.5
 Orbital pairs:                    32      16      16       8      24      16      16       8
 Strings:                         944    1008    1008    1016    1000    1008    1008    1016
                                  516     546     546     576     516     546     546     576
 Determinants:                4375008 4372368 4372368 4369728 4375008 4372368 4372368 4369728

 Load integrals                1.1 sec
 Transform integrals           1.1 sec
 Storage for integrals:           3280
 Remaining memory:           499995784

 Core energy:            -117.82021401
 Run Hamiltonian processor DAVIDSON
 Symmetry:                   2
 Trial vector:                  0.00
 Result vector:                 0.00
 Maximum iterations:           90
 Convergence threshold:         0.0000100
 RHS vector:                    0.00
 Hamiltonian shift:             0.0000000
 Output threshold:              0.0500000
 Options:                        0
 Number of roots:             1

 Hamiltonian diagonaliser entered at time      1.09

 Initial configuration generated:
 2841857      1.0000000   -148.7666251

 It  Tr    CPU  Convergence   Energy       Pop     dE(next)

  1   1    5.5  1.00000000  -148.76662508
                                           0.00 -0.20142677 -0.20142673
  2   1    8.8  0.28920310  -148.92680490
                                           0.00 -0.06089453 -0.06085774
  3   1   12.2  0.06457901  -148.94050417
                                           0.00 -0.02554979 -0.02551080
  4   1   15.7  0.06841448  -148.95168086
                                           0.01 -0.01371921 -0.01365907
  5   1   19.2  0.05931640  -148.95717720
                                           0.02 -0.00370189 -0.00367481
  6   1   23.0  0.06716380  -148.96100662
                                           0.01 -0.00505173 -0.00499344
  7   1   26.7  0.07897016  -148.96634343
                                           0.02 -0.00630381 -0.00622174
  8   1   30.6  0.10335030  -148.97533161
                                           0.02 -0.01001495 -0.00989341
  9   1   34.5  0.05509516  -148.98016886
                                           0.03 -0.00343698 -0.00338590
 10   1   38.8  0.03531415  -148.98254455
                                           0.04 -0.00096568 -0.00094615
 11   1   43.0  0.02055238  -148.98323756
                                           0.02 -0.00080353 -0.00078392
 12   1   47.1  0.01319352  -148.98365292
                                           0.03 -0.00058690 -0.00057170
 13   1   51.3  0.01929560  -148.98421419
                                           0.03 -0.00080892 -0.00079005
 14   1   55.6  0.02023198  -148.98499451
                                           0.05 -0.00048575 -0.00047311
 15   1   60.2  0.01288664  -148.98546138
                                           0.06 -0.00018223 -0.00017651
 16   1   65.0  0.00570344  -148.98558745
                                           0.05 -0.00006935 -0.00006649
 17   1   70.0  0.00641564  -148.98564428
                                           0.04 -0.00005106 -0.00004895
 18   1   74.9  0.00578983  -148.98569021
                                           0.05 -0.00005543 -0.00005304
 19   1   79.8  0.00532350  -148.98575311
                                           0.07 -0.00006757 -0.00006511
 20   1   85.0  0.00325370  -148.98580145
                                           0.08 -0.00003949 -0.00003797
 21   1   90.4  0.00293902  -148.98583088
                                           0.06 -0.00002262 -0.00002155
 22   1   95.6  0.00309529  -148.98585009
                                           0.05 -0.00002216 -0.00002107
 23   1  100.6  0.00934947  -148.98589674
                                           0.06 -0.00013156 -0.00012716
 24   1  105.9  0.18779262  -149.01713176
                                           0.08 -0.06229898 -0.06089126
 25   1  111.6  0.07876286  -149.05332481
                                           0.07 -0.01592462 -0.01554368
 26   1  117.3  0.04142281  -149.06253299
                                           0.07 -0.00341228 -0.00331947
 27   1  122.8  0.01997974  -149.06454372
                                           0.06 -0.00136162 -0.00131753
 28   1  128.3  0.01429352  -149.06536820
                                           0.06 -0.00070391 -0.00067857
 29   1  133.8  0.01667635  -149.06597477
                                           0.06 -0.00057433 -0.00055489
 30   1  139.4  0.01943463  -149.06660837
                                           0.07 -0.00064658 -0.00062447
 31   1  145.2  0.01212161  -149.06713334
                                           0.09 -0.00041335 -0.00039968
 32   1  151.3  0.00894645  -149.06745088
                                           0.08 -0.00022313 -0.00021480
 33   1  157.3  0.00693744  -149.06761507
                                           0.07 -0.00011317 -0.00010845
 34   1  163.3  0.00646436  -149.06771419
                                           0.06 -0.00010857 -0.00010392
 35   1  169.1  0.00739403  -149.06782196
                                           0.08 -0.00012348 -0.00011847
 36   1  175.2  0.00729493  -149.06794570
                                           0.09 -0.00011672 -0.00011234
 37   1  181.5  0.00436059  -149.06803161
                                           0.08 -0.00007376 -0.00007064
 38   1  187.8  0.00273583  -149.06807643
                                           0.10 -0.00002215 -0.00002110
 39   1  194.4  0.00201035  -149.06809285
                                           0.09 -0.00000848 -0.00000799
 40   1  201.0  0.00135315  -149.06809875
                                           0.08 -0.00000467 -0.00000437
 41   1  207.4  0.00168650  -149.06810347
                                           0.08 -0.00000443 -0.00000416
 42   1  213.7  0.00220462  -149.06810952
                                           0.10 -0.00000772 -0.00000727
 43   1  220.4  0.00283501  -149.06812133
                                           0.10 -0.00002031 -0.00001924
 44   1  227.2  0.01569829  -149.06822326
                                           0.07 -0.00065329 -0.00062303
 45   1  233.5  0.15390731  -149.10354714
                                           0.07 -0.05480024 -0.05227691
 46   1  240.0  0.15535612  -149.15747853
                                           0.10 -0.04986011 -0.04776101
 47   1  246.9  0.08261332  -149.19108361
                                           0.11 -0.02074825 -0.01991916
 48   1  254.1  0.03966539  -149.20255582
                                           0.11 -0.00592552 -0.00569765
 49   1  261.2  0.02009157  -149.20580362
                                           0.11 -0.00146979 -0.00140991
 50   1  268.4  0.01169597  -149.20669087
                                           0.11 -0.00038586 -0.00036873
 51   1  275.5  0.00706450  -149.20693637
                                           0.10 -0.00013238 -0.00012560
 52   1  282.6  0.00533483  -149.20703050
                                           0.09 -0.00007025 -0.00006618
 53   1  289.5  0.00436481  -149.20708339
                                           0.10 -0.00004369 -0.00004122
 54   1  296.7  0.00311963  -149.20711525
                                           0.10 -0.00002952 -0.00002777
 55   1  303.9  0.00211586  -149.20713440
                                           0.13 -0.00001238 -0.00001166
 56   1  311.5  0.00138472  -149.20714328
                                           0.12 -0.00000516 -0.00000482
 57   1  319.1  0.00082415  -149.20714661
                                           0.12 -0.00000222 -0.00000206
 58   1  326.9  0.00057880  -149.20714801
                                           0.10 -0.00000120 -0.00000111
 59   1  334.4  0.00050949  -149.20714885
                                           0.11 -0.00000067 -0.00000062
 60   1  342.1  0.00043921  -149.20714940
                                           0.11 -0.00000044 -0.00000040
 61   1  349.8  0.00026590  -149.20714969
                                           0.14 -0.00000023 -0.00000021
 62   1  358.1  0.00018086  -149.20714984
                                           0.15 -0.00000011 -0.00000010
 63   1  366.4  0.00011416  -149.20714991
                                           0.15 -0.00000004 -0.00000004
 64   1  374.9  0.00008633  -149.20714994
                                           0.13 -0.00000002 -0.00000002
 65   1  383.1  0.00006807  -149.20714995
                                           0.11 -0.00000001 -0.00000001
 66   1  391.2  0.00005559  -149.20714996
                                           0.12 -0.00000001 -0.00000001
 67   1  399.4  0.00004707  -149.20714997
                                           0.16 -0.00000001 -0.00000001
 68   1  408.1  0.00003472  -149.20714997
                                           0.15 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 69   1  416.8  0.00002649  -149.20714998
                                           0.14 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 70   1  425.3  0.00002221  -149.20714998
                                           0.13 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 71   1  433.9  0.00001837  -149.20714998
                                           0.13 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 72   1  442.4  0.00001378  -149.20714998
                                           0.15 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 73   1  451.3  0.00000931  -149.20714998


RESULTS FOR STATE 1.2
=====================

 Correlation energy                    -0.440524901040
 !FCI STATE 1.2 Energy               -149.207149980258
 CI Vector (threshold= 0.500E-01)
      -0.183340306743  1  2  3  9 11 12 15 17  1  2  3  4  7 11 15
      -0.183328490380  1  2  3  4 11 12 15 17  1  2  3  7  9 11 15
      -0.154683231778  1  2  3  4  7  9 11 15  1  2  3  4  7 11 17
       0.149208986991  1  2  3  4  7  9 11 15  1  2  3  4  9 11 15
      -0.154630007758  1  2  3  4  7  9 11 15  1  2  3  7  9 11 12
      -0.338069277678  1  2  3  4  7  9 11 15  1  2  3 11 12 15 17
      -0.154554456655  1  2  3  7 11 12 15 17  1  2  3  4  7 11 17
       0.337917604867  1  2  3  7 11 12 15 17  1  2  3  4  9 11 15
      -0.154529786126  1  2  3  7 11 12 15 17  1  2  3  7  9 11 12
      -0.149139451947  1  2  3  7 11 12 15 17  1  2  3 11 12 15 17
       0.183342250193  1  2  3  4  9 11 15 17  1  2  3  7 11 12 15
       0.188812623514  1  2  3  4  7 11 12 15  1  2  3  9 11 15 17
      -0.188833142542  1  2  3  7  9 11 15 17  1  2  3  4 11 12 15
      -0.183334288028  1  2  3  4  9 11 12 15  1  2  3  7 11 15 17
      -0.154534183010  1  2  3  4  7 11 15 17  1  2  3  4  7  9 11
      -0.149137290249  1  2  3  4  7 11 15 17  1  2  3  4 11 15 17
       0.154555950298  1  2  3  4  7 11 15 17  1  2  3  7 11 12 17
      -0.337913822218  1  2  3  4  7 11 15 17  1  2  3  9 11 12 15
       0.154627537182  1  2  3  7  9 11 12 15  1  2  3  4  7  9 11
       0.338072625710  1  2  3  7  9 11 12 15  1  2  3  4 11 15 17
      -0.154680007374  1  2  3  7  9 11 12 15  1  2  3  7 11 12 17
       0.149211470451  1  2  3  7  9 11 12 15  1  2  3  9 11 12 15
 /EOF
 !FCI STATE 1.2 Dipole moment           0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000


 !FCI expec          <0.2|EREL|0.2>    -0.103256661228

 !FCI expec        <0.2|DARWIN|0.2>     0.391700604257

 !FCI expec         <0.2|MASSV|0.2>    -0.494957265485


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      21        7.58       500      610      700      900      950      970     1001      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700     1380   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER     JKOP   
                                         1700(1)
                                         OPER   

              2       6        0.34       700     1000      520     2140     1001     2141   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF    BASIS    MCSCF   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL       FCI     MCSCF       INT     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *       379.46    378.58      0.23      0.02      0.12      0.03
 REAL TIME  *       454.38 SEC
 DISK USED  *         5.15 GB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

        FCI             MCSCF           MCSCF   
   -149.20714998   -149.06607774   -147.24773391
 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 Variable memory released
-------------- next part --------------

 Primary working directories    : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Secondary working directories  : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Wavefunction directory         : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Main file repository           : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/

 SHA1      : 2c68d29c09da70e1723824271fadde4bcd5f07a0
 ARCHNAME  : Linux/x86_64
 FC        : /usr/bin/gfortran
 FCVERSION : 4.4.6
 BLASLIB   : -L/usr/lib64/atlas -lf77blas -lcblas -latlas
 id        : uclcc

 Nodes                            nprocs
 secondprize.theory.phys.ucl.ac.uk    1

 Using customized tuning parameters: mindgm=1; mindgv=20; mindgc=4; mindgr=1; noblas=0; minvec=7
 default implementation of scratch files=df  

 ***,Calculation for oxygen atom
 MEMORY,     500.00, M
 GEXPEC, DM, REL, DARW, MASSV, LOP
 GPRINT, DISTANCE, ANGLES, VARIABLE
 
 geometry = {O}
 basis={default, 6-31G}
 
                                                                                 ! oxygen 3P^e ground state
 {MCSCF
  OCC, 2,1,1,0,1,0,0,0; CLOSED,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0; FROZEN,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0;
  WF, ELEC=8, SYM=4, SPIN=2;
  WF, ELEC=8, SYM=6, SPIN=2;
  WF, ELEC=8, SYM=7, SPIN=2;
 }
 
 {FCI; CORE,1}

 Variables initialized (766), CPU time= 0.01 sec
 Commands  initialized (545), CPU time= 0.03 sec, 513 directives.
 Default parameters read. Elapsed time= 0.07 sec

 Checking input...
 Passed
1


                                         ***  PROGRAM SYSTEM MOLPRO  ***
                         Copyright, University College Cardiff Consultants Limited, 2008

                                    Version 2012.1 linked 26 Apr 2013 18:03:55


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 LABEL *   Calculation for oxygen atom                                                   
 Linux-2.6.32-573.12.1.el6.x86_64/secondprize.theory.phys.ucl.ac.uk(x86_64) 64 bit serialDATE: 12-Feb-16          TIME: 16:11:19  
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

 SHA1:             2c68d29c09da70e1723824271fadde4bcd5f07a0
 **********************************************************************************************************************************


 Variable memory set to  500000000 words,  buffer space   230000 words

 SETTING BASIS          =    6-31G


 Recomputing integrals since basis changed


 Using spherical harmonics

 Library entry O      S 6-31G                selected for orbital group  1
 Library entry O      P 6-31G                selected for orbital group  1

1PROGRAM * SEWARD (Integral evaluation for generally contracted gaussian basis sets)     Author: Roland Lindh, 1990

 Geometry written to block  1 of record 700

 Orientation using atomic masses  
 Molecule type: Atom
 Symmetry elements: X,Y,Z
 Rotational constants:       0.0000000      0.0000000      0.0000000 GHz  (calculated with average atomic masses)

 Point group  D2h 



 ATOMIC COORDINATES

 NR  ATOM    CHARGE       X              Y              Z

   1  O       8.00    0.000000000    0.000000000    0.000000000

 NUCLEAR CHARGE:                    8
 NUMBER OF PRIMITIVE AOS:          22
 NUMBER OF SYMMETRY AOS:           22
 NUMBER OF CONTRACTIONS:            9   (   3Ag  +   2B3u +   2B2u +   0B1g +   2B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF CORE ORBITALS:           1   (   1Ag  +   0B3u +   0B2u +   0B1g +   0B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF VALENCE ORBITALS:        4   (   1Ag  +   1B3u +   1B2u +   0B1g +   1B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )


 NUCLEAR REPULSION ENERGY    0.00000000


 Eigenvalues of metric

         1 0.233E+00 0.909E+00 0.186E+01
         2 0.498E+00 0.150E+01
         3 0.498E+00 0.150E+01
         5 0.498E+00 0.150E+01


 Contracted 2-electron integrals neglected if value below      1.0D-11
 AO integral compression algorithm  1   Integral accuracy      1.0D-11

     0.262 MB (compressed) written to integral file (100.0%)


 NUMBER OF SORTED TWO-ELECTRON INTEGRALS:        282.     BUFFER LENGTH:  32768
 NUMBER OF SEGMENTS:   1  SEGMENT LENGTH:        282      RECORD LENGTH: 524288

 Memory used in sort:       0.56 MW

 SORT1 READ         633. AND WROTE         282. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.00 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.00 SEC
 SORT2 READ         282. AND WROTE         282. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.00 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.01 SEC

 FILE SIZES:   FILE 1:     7.8 MBYTE,  FILE 4:     4.2 MBYTE,   TOTAL:     12.0 MBYTE

 OPERATOR DM      FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR REL     FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR DARW    FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR MASSV   FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR LOP     FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      19        7.50       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.36      0.02
 REAL TIME  *         0.39 SEC
 DISK USED  *        12.23 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

1PROGRAM * MULTI (Direct Multiconfiguration SCF)       Authors: P.J. Knowles, H.-J. Werner (1984)     S.T. Elbert (1988)


 Number of closed-shell orbitals:   1 (   1   0   0   0   0   0   0   0 )
 Number of active  orbitals:        4 (   1   1   1   0   1   0   0   0 )
 Number of external orbitals:       4 (   1   1   1   0   1   0   0   0 )

 State symmetry 1

 Number of electrons:     6    Spin symmetry=Triplet   Space symmetry=4
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:          1   (1 determinants, 6 intermediate states)

 State symmetry 2

 Number of electrons:     6    Spin symmetry=Triplet   Space symmetry=6
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:          1   (1 determinants, 6 intermediate states)

 State symmetry 3

 Number of electrons:     6    Spin symmetry=Triplet   Space symmetry=7
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:          1   (1 determinants, 6 intermediate states)

 Orbital guess generated from atomic densities. Full valence occupancy:    2   1   1   0   1   0   0   0


 Wavefunction dump at record             2140.2

 Convergence thresholds  0.10E-01 (gradient)  0.10E-05 (energy)  0.10E-02 (step length)

 Weight factors for state symmetry  1:    0.33333
 Weight factors for state symmetry  2:    0.33333
 Weight factors for state symmetry  3:    0.33333

 Number of orbital rotations:        6   (     1 Core/Active      1 Core/Virtual   0 Active/Active      4 Active/Virtual)
 Total number of variables:          9


 ITER. MIC  NCI  NEG     ENERGY(VAR)     ENERGY(PROJ)   ENERGY CHANGE     GRAD(0)  GRAD(ORB)   GRAD(CI)     STEP       TIME

   1   28   12    0     -74.76161751     -74.77718716   -0.01556965    0.21167577 0.00006822 0.00000000  0.78D-01      0.02
   2   15   12    0     -74.77687333     -74.77688628   -0.00001295    0.00611555 0.00000007 0.00000000  0.22D-02      0.02
   3   16   12    0     -74.77688629     -74.77688629   -0.00000000    0.00000503 0.00000000 0.00000000  0.18D-05      0.02

 ** WVFN ****  CONVERGENCE REACHED, FINAL GRADIENT:  0.29D-11



 Results for state 1.4
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.4 Energy              -74.776886287642
 Nuclear energy                         0.00000000
 Kinetic energy                        74.68143155
 One electron energy                 -103.21634131
 Two electron energy                   28.43945503
 Virial ratio                           2.00127816

 !MCSCF STATE 1.4 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000



 Results for state 1.6
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.6 Energy              -74.776886287642
 Nuclear energy                         0.00000000
 Kinetic energy                        74.68143155
 One electron energy                 -103.21634131
 Two electron energy                   28.43945503
 Virial ratio                           2.00127816

 !MCSCF STATE 1.6 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000



 Results for state 1.7
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.7 Energy              -74.776886287642
 Nuclear energy                         0.00000000
 Kinetic energy                        74.68143155
 One electron energy                 -103.21634131
 Two electron energy                   28.43945503
 Virial ratio                           2.00127816

 !MCSCF STATE 1.7 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000

 State-averaged charge density matrix saved on record  2140.2 (density set 1)

 !MCSCF expec        <1.4|EREL|1.4>    -0.051571773667
 !MCSCF expec        <1.6|EREL|1.6>    -0.051571773667
 !MCSCF expec        <1.7|EREL|1.7>    -0.051571773667

 !MCSCF expec      <1.4|DARWIN|1.4>     0.195616531189
 !MCSCF expec      <1.6|DARWIN|1.6>     0.195616531189
 !MCSCF expec      <1.7|DARWIN|1.7>     0.195616531189

 !MCSCF expec       <1.4|MASSV|1.4>    -0.247188304856
 !MCSCF expec       <1.6|MASSV|1.6>    -0.247188304856
 !MCSCF expec       <1.7|MASSV|1.7>    -0.247188304856

 !MCSCF trans          <1.6|LX|1.4>     1.000000000000i

 !MCSCF trans          <1.7|LY|1.4>     1.000000000000i

 !MCSCF trans          <1.7|LZ|1.6>     1.000000000000i


 Natural orbital dump (state averaged) at molpro section  2140.2    (Orbital set 2)



 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      20        7.50       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700     1380   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER     JKOP   

              2       4        0.28       700     1000      520     2140   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.39      0.03      0.02
 REAL TIME  *         0.46 SEC
 DISK USED  *        16.16 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

1PROGRAM * FCI (Full CI)     Author: P.J. Knowles, 1984

 ***  Initialisation ***

 Molecular orbitals read from record     2140.2  Type=MCSCF/NATURAL  

 Frozen orbitals:              1 (  1  0  0  0  0  0  0  0)
 Active orbitals:              8 (  2  2  2  0  2  0  0  0)
 Active electrons:             6
 Spin quantum number:          1.0
 Orbital pairs:                    12       4       4       4       4       4       4       0
 Strings:                           6       8       8       8       8       8       8      16
                                    4       4       4       4       4       4       4       0
 Determinants:                    216     248     248     248     248     248     248     256

 Load integrals                0.5 sec
 Transform integrals           0.5 sec
 Storage for integrals:            376
 Remaining memory:           499999315

 Core energy:             -59.10142249
 Run Hamiltonian processor DAVIDSON
 Symmetry:                   4
 Trial vector:                  0.00
 Result vector:                 0.00
 Maximum iterations:           90
 Convergence threshold:         0.0000100
 RHS vector:                    0.00
 Hamiltonian shift:             0.0000000
 Output threshold:              0.0500000
 Options:                        0
 Number of roots:             1

 Hamiltonian diagonaliser entered at time      0.52

 Initial configuration generated:
     121      1.0000000    -74.7768863

 It  Tr    CPU  Convergence   Energy       Pop     dE(next)

  1   1    0.5  1.00000000   -74.77688629
                                           0.12 -0.07174031 -0.07016981
  2   1    0.5  0.13317899   -74.83456219
                                           0.24 -0.00397684 -0.00378380
  3   1    0.5  0.03924984   -74.83813056
                                           0.29 -0.00042187 -0.00035205
  4   1    0.5  0.01106491   -74.83846888
                                           0.30 -0.00008532 -0.00007283
  5   1    0.5  0.00457523   -74.83854255
                                           0.31 -0.00001346 -0.00001137
  6   1    0.5  0.00168591   -74.83855403
                                           0.29 -0.00000210 -0.00000180
  7   1    0.5  0.00065242   -74.83855579
                                           0.28 -0.00000035 -0.00000030
  8   1    0.5  0.00028844   -74.83855610
                                           0.27 -0.00000005 -0.00000004
  9   1    0.5  0.00010581   -74.83855614
                                           0.30 -0.00000001 -0.00000001
 10   1    0.5  0.00003670   -74.83855614
                                           0.29 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 11   1    0.5  0.00001765   -74.83855615
                                           0.28 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 12   1    0.5  0.00000586   -74.83855615


RESULTS FOR STATE 1.4
=====================

 Correlation energy                    -0.061669857614
 !FCI STATE 1.4 Energy                -74.838556145256
 CI Vector (threshold= 0.500E-01)
       0.989130691513  1  2  4  6  8  1  2  8
      -0.055106366543  1  2  4  6  9  1  2  9
 /EOF
 !FCI STATE 1.4 Dipole moment           0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000


 !FCI expec          <0.4|EREL|0.4>    -0.051537107560

 !FCI expec        <0.4|DARWIN|0.4>     0.195540805254

 !FCI expec         <0.4|MASSV|0.4>    -0.247077912814



 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      20        7.50       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700     1380   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER     JKOP   

              2       4        0.28       700     1000      520     2140   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL       FCI     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.44      0.01      0.03      0.02
 REAL TIME  *         0.51 SEC
 DISK USED  *        16.16 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

        FCI             MCSCF   
    -74.83855615    -74.77688629
 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 Variable memory released
-------------- next part --------------

 Primary working directories    : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Secondary working directories  : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Wavefunction directory         : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/
 Main file repository           : /scratch/vol0/lorenzo/

 SHA1      : 2c68d29c09da70e1723824271fadde4bcd5f07a0
 ARCHNAME  : Linux/x86_64
 FC        : /usr/bin/gfortran
 FCVERSION : 4.4.6
 BLASLIB   : -L/usr/lib64/atlas -lf77blas -lcblas -latlas
 id        : uclcc

 Nodes                            nprocs
 secondprize.theory.phys.ucl.ac.uk    1

 Using customized tuning parameters: mindgm=1; mindgv=20; mindgc=4; mindgr=1; noblas=0; minvec=7
 default implementation of scratch files=df  

 ***,Calculation for oxygen+
 MEMORY,     500.00, M
 GEXPEC, DM, REL, DARW, MASSV, LOP
 GPRINT, DISTANCE, ANGLES, VARIABLE
 
 
 geometry = {O}
 
 basis={default, 6-31G}
 
                                                                                 ! oxygen+ 4S^o ground state
 {MCSCF
  OCC, 2,1,1,0,1,0,0,0; CLOSED,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0; FROZEN,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0;
  WF, ELEC=7, SYM=8, SPIN=3;
 }
 
 {FCI; CORE,1}
 

 Variables initialized (766), CPU time= 0.01 sec
 Commands  initialized (545), CPU time= 0.03 sec, 513 directives.
 Default parameters read. Elapsed time= 0.07 sec

 Checking input...
 Passed
1


                                         ***  PROGRAM SYSTEM MOLPRO  ***
                         Copyright, University College Cardiff Consultants Limited, 2008

                                    Version 2012.1 linked 26 Apr 2013 18:03:55


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 LABEL *   Calculation for oxygen+                                                       
 Linux-2.6.32-573.12.1.el6.x86_64/secondprize.theory.phys.ucl.ac.uk(x86_64) 64 bit serialDATE: 12-Feb-16          TIME: 16:10:57  
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

 SHA1:             2c68d29c09da70e1723824271fadde4bcd5f07a0
 **********************************************************************************************************************************


 Variable memory set to  500000000 words,  buffer space   230000 words

 SETTING BASIS          =    6-31G


 Recomputing integrals since basis changed


 Using spherical harmonics

 Library entry O      S 6-31G                selected for orbital group  1
 Library entry O      P 6-31G                selected for orbital group  1

1PROGRAM * SEWARD (Integral evaluation for generally contracted gaussian basis sets)     Author: Roland Lindh, 1990

 Geometry written to block  1 of record 700

 Orientation using atomic masses  
 Molecule type: Atom
 Symmetry elements: X,Y,Z
 Rotational constants:       0.0000000      0.0000000      0.0000000 GHz  (calculated with average atomic masses)

 Point group  D2h 



 ATOMIC COORDINATES

 NR  ATOM    CHARGE       X              Y              Z

   1  O       8.00    0.000000000    0.000000000    0.000000000

 NUCLEAR CHARGE:                    8
 NUMBER OF PRIMITIVE AOS:          22
 NUMBER OF SYMMETRY AOS:           22
 NUMBER OF CONTRACTIONS:            9   (   3Ag  +   2B3u +   2B2u +   0B1g +   2B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF CORE ORBITALS:           1   (   1Ag  +   0B3u +   0B2u +   0B1g +   0B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )
 NUMBER OF VALENCE ORBITALS:        4   (   1Ag  +   1B3u +   1B2u +   0B1g +   1B1u +   0B2g +   0B3g +   0Au  )


 NUCLEAR REPULSION ENERGY    0.00000000


 Eigenvalues of metric

         1 0.233E+00 0.909E+00 0.186E+01
         2 0.498E+00 0.150E+01
         3 0.498E+00 0.150E+01
         5 0.498E+00 0.150E+01


 Contracted 2-electron integrals neglected if value below      1.0D-11
 AO integral compression algorithm  1   Integral accuracy      1.0D-11

     0.262 MB (compressed) written to integral file (100.0%)


 NUMBER OF SORTED TWO-ELECTRON INTEGRALS:        282.     BUFFER LENGTH:  32768
 NUMBER OF SEGMENTS:   1  SEGMENT LENGTH:        282      RECORD LENGTH: 524288

 Memory used in sort:       0.56 MW

 SORT1 READ         633. AND WROTE         282. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.00 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.00 SEC
 SORT2 READ         282. AND WROTE         282. INTEGRALS IN      1 RECORDS. CPU TIME:     0.00 SEC, REAL TIME:     0.01 SEC

 FILE SIZES:   FILE 1:     7.8 MBYTE,  FILE 4:     4.2 MBYTE,   TOTAL:     12.0 MBYTE

 OPERATOR DM      FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR REL     FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR DARW    FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR MASSV   FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000
 OPERATOR LOP     FOR CENTER  0  COORDINATES:    0.000000    0.000000    0.000000


 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      19        7.50       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.37      0.03
 REAL TIME  *         0.39 SEC
 DISK USED  *        12.23 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

1PROGRAM * MULTI (Direct Multiconfiguration SCF)       Authors: P.J. Knowles, H.-J. Werner (1984)     S.T. Elbert (1988)


 Number of closed-shell orbitals:   1 (   1   0   0   0   0   0   0   0 )
 Number of active  orbitals:        4 (   1   1   1   0   1   0   0   0 )
 Number of external orbitals:       4 (   1   1   1   0   1   0   0   0 )

 State symmetry 1

 Number of electrons:     5    Spin symmetry=Quartet   Space symmetry=8
 Number of states:        1
 Number of CSFs:          1   (1 determinants, 4 intermediate states)

 Orbital guess generated from atomic densities. Full valence occupancy:    2   1   1   0   1   0   0   0


 Wavefunction dump at record             2140.2

 Convergence thresholds  0.10E-01 (gradient)  0.10E-05 (energy)  0.10E-02 (step length)

 Number of orbital rotations:        6   (     1 Core/Active      1 Core/Virtual   0 Active/Active      4 Active/Virtual)
 Total number of variables:          7


 ITER. MIC  NCI  NEG     ENERGY(VAR)     ENERGY(PROJ)   ENERGY CHANGE     GRAD(0)  GRAD(ORB)   GRAD(CI)     STEP       TIME

   1   19    7    0     -74.18238938     -74.34361320   -0.16122381    0.62613303 0.00242811 0.00000000  0.29D+00      0.01
   2   15    4    0     -74.33590315     -74.33650146   -0.00059831    0.03928559 0.00001062 0.00000000  0.17D-01      0.01
   3   12    4    0     -74.33650303     -74.33650304   -0.00000001    0.00015538 0.00000000 0.00000000  0.67D-04      0.01

 ** WVFN ****  CONVERGENCE REACHED, FINAL GRADIENT:  0.24D-08


 First order charge density matrix for state 1.8 saved on record  2140.2 (density set 1)

 Results for state 1.8
 =====================

 !MCSCF STATE 1.8 Energy              -74.336503036655
 Nuclear energy                         0.00000000
 Kinetic energy                        74.20094094
 One electron energy                  -98.35294637
 Two electron energy                   24.01644333
 Virial ratio                           2.00182696

 !MCSCF STATE 1.8 Dipole moment         0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000

 !MCSCF expec        <1.8|EREL|1.8>    -0.051758097817

 !MCSCF expec      <1.8|DARWIN|1.8>     0.196225181096

 !MCSCF expec       <1.8|MASSV|1.8>    -0.247983278913


 Natural orbital dump at molpro section  2140.2    (Orbital set 2)



 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      20        7.50       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700     1380   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER     JKOP   

              2       4        0.28       700     1000      520     2140   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.38      0.01      0.03
 REAL TIME  *         0.41 SEC
 DISK USED  *        12.23 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

1PROGRAM * FCI (Full CI)     Author: P.J. Knowles, 1984

 ***  Initialisation ***

 Molecular orbitals read from record     2140.2  Type=MCSCF/NATURAL (state 1.8)

 Frozen orbitals:              1 (  1  0  0  0  0  0  0  0)
 Active orbitals:              8 (  2  2  2  0  2  0  0  0)
 Active electrons:             5
 Spin quantum number:          1.5
 Orbital pairs:                    12       4       4       4       4       4       4       0
 Strings:                           6       8       8       8       8       8       8      16
                                    2       2       2       0       2       0       0       0
 Determinants:                     60      60      60      80      60      80      80      80

 Load integrals                0.5 sec
 Transform integrals           0.5 sec
 Storage for integrals:            376
 Remaining memory:           499999315

 Core energy:             -59.10180215
 Run Hamiltonian processor DAVIDSON
 Symmetry:                   8
 Trial vector:                  0.00
 Result vector:                 0.00
 Maximum iterations:           90
 Convergence threshold:         0.0000100
 RHS vector:                    0.00
 Hamiltonian shift:             0.0000000
 Output threshold:              0.0500000
 Options:                        0
 Number of roots:             1

 Hamiltonian diagonaliser entered at time      0.48

 Initial configuration generated:
       1      1.0000000    -74.3365030

 It  Tr    CPU  Convergence   Energy       Pop     dE(next)

  1   1    0.5  1.00000000   -74.33650304
                                           0.23 -0.03374640 -0.03180015
  2   1    0.5  0.09806352   -74.36573695
                                           0.13 -0.00286779 -0.00229354
  3   1    0.5  0.02720364   -74.36811902
                                           0.29 -0.00049306 -0.00044825
  4   1    0.5  0.00926026   -74.36850358
                                           0.34 -0.00005414 -0.00004714
  5   1    0.5  0.00369468   -74.36854871
                                           0.24 -0.00000938 -0.00000717
  6   1    0.5  0.00134433   -74.36855544
                                           0.28 -0.00000203 -0.00000168
  7   1    0.5  0.00062928   -74.36855722
                                           0.30 -0.00000029 -0.00000025
  8   1    0.5  0.00027262   -74.36855747
                                           0.29 -0.00000003 -0.00000003
  9   1    0.5  0.00009409   -74.36855750
                                           0.24 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 10   1    0.5  0.00002411   -74.36855751
                                           0.34 -0.00000000 -0.00000000
 11   1    0.5  0.00000976   -74.36855751


RESULTS FOR STATE 1.8
=====================

 Correlation energy                    -0.032054468734
 !FCI STATE 1.8 Energy                -74.368557505389
 CI Vector (threshold= 0.500E-01)
       0.994478805552  1  2  4  6  8  1  2
 /EOF
 !FCI STATE 1.8 Dipole moment           0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000
 Dipole moment /Debye                   0.00000000     0.00000000     0.00000000


 !FCI expec          <1.8|EREL|1.8>    -0.051707059385

 !FCI expec        <1.8|DARWIN|1.8>     0.196118424995

 !FCI expec         <1.8|MASSV|1.8>    -0.247825484380



 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 DATASETS  * FILE   NREC   LENGTH (MB)   RECORD NAMES
              1      20        7.50       500      610      700      900      950      970     1000      129      960     1100   
                                          VAR    BASINP    GEOM    SYMINP    ZMAT    AOBASIS   BASIS     P2S    ABASIS      S 
                                         1400     1410     1200     1210     1080     1600     1650     1300     1700     1380   
                                           T        V       H0       H01     AOSYM     SMH    MOLCAS    ERIS     OPER     JKOP   

              2       4        0.28       700     1000      520     2140   
                                         GEOM     BASIS   MCVARS    MCSCF   

 PROGRAMS   *        TOTAL       FCI     MCSCF       INT
 CPU TIMES  *         0.43      0.01      0.01      0.03
 REAL TIME  *         0.46 SEC
 DISK USED  *        12.23 MB      
 **********************************************************************************************************************************

        FCI             MCSCF   
    -74.36855751    -74.33650304
 **********************************************************************************************************************************
 Variable memory released


More information about the Molpro-user mailing list